From Geoff Seidner
TO AUJS PRESIDENT
Please respond
http://cognatesocialistdystopia.blogspot.com.au/2013/11/dean-sherr-asinine-boycott-boon-to.html
the orig article unexpurgated above
This article is all wrong in multiple ways
- It is written by an ostensible antagonist of Israel who has enveigled himself into becoming the political affairs director, Australasian Union of Jewish Students.
- Claiming that the extensive verbiage ''are his personal views'' is pathetic! He does not thus vitiate the disingenuous tripe by claiming the pathetic moniker / cover of 'personal opinion'!
- Indeed he will be quoted by enemies of Israel: NO EXCUSES FOR THIS STANDARD CANARD USED BY ENEMIES OF THE MIDDLE - EAST's ONLY DEMOCRACY!
- Or is he simply stupid? I think I know not. And care not!
There are many major chimeras this disingenuous twirp
has
created: I
care not to contemplate whether an unfortunate allocation of genes was
responsible! I
certainly do
not have the time to didactically comment on all of this person's trite
antithetical – to common sense
essay.
It is simpler
to treat him as an enemy of Israel.
It will be up
to the AUJ to sack him and ask themselves why they appointed him!
Why
indeed.
What a waste
youth are!!
It is their
dichotomous problem!
THE PLAIN
CHIMERAS
- The moron uses idiotic words to denote a mythical Israeli as ''hawkish,,, right - wing... rubbing hands
- with glee....right - wing Zionists...sceptical of peace concessions and negotiations...'' This and the rest
- is pathetic. I have no time to discuss further......
- But he gets worse: he not only continues this ad nausium - but manages to set up the ''hawkish' ones to
- be - devilled via his ''ammunition'' phrase!
- AND worse - AND THIS IS THE ONE FOR AN ESSAY I HAVE BEEN LONGING TO WRITE
- FOR A LONG TIME: on ‘’criticisms of Israel’’
IT WILL SAVE A LOT OF TIME IN THE
FUTURE IF I EVER FIND THE LIKES OF
SHERR
AGAIN IN MY TRAVELS AND
TRAVAILS!!
I HAVE NO
TIME FOR NOW; to be continued when I have a response from the
AUJS.
Structurally
- this scribble is a mess: let us see their response when I will contemplate
rewriting it!
Plainly I am running out of
time....
Geoff
Seidner
in·vei·gle
[in-vey-guh
l, -vee-] Show IPA
verb (used with object), in·vei·gled, in·vei·gling.
1.
to entice, lure, or ensnare by flattery or artful talk or inducements (usually followed by into ): toinveigle a person into playing bridge.
2.
to acquire, win, or obtain by beguiling talk or methods (usually followed by from or away ): toinveigle a theater pass from a person.
l, -vee-] Show IPA
verb (used with object), in·vei·gled, in·vei·gling.
1.
to entice, lure, or ensnare by flattery or artful talk or inducements (usually followed by into ): toinveigle a person into playing bridge.
2.
to acquire, win, or obtain by beguiling talk or methods (usually followed by from or away ): toinveigle a theater pass from a person.
Boycott boon to Israel's right
SOMEWHERE
in Jerusalem, a man in a blue tie is reading about an academic in Sydney
boycotting a left-wing Israeli educator. He's a hawkish politician, a member of
a right-wing party, and he's rubbing his hands together in
glee.
He's happy because his political
opponents, Israeli peace advocates, are being slapped down and dismissed, not
just by the Right but by the Left. Dan Avnon, who developed a civics program to
promote equality for minorities and create a shared understanding between
Israelis and Palestinians, is being boycotted by a Sydney University centre
because he's Israeli.
Boycott, divestment and
sanctions is a contradictory movement. Supported by the far Left here, it
ironically provides great support to the Israeli Right. Right-wing Zionists,
often sceptical of peace concessions and negotiations, can find no better case to throw in the face of the
Left. Israelis uninterested in making peace with
Palestinians can only laugh when Israelis who dedicate and sacrifice so much to do
so find themselves rejected, delegitimised as human beings, simply because
they're Israeli.
Israelis, bearing
anti-Semitism and disproportionate criticism in mind, don't find it hard to feel
persecuted or targeted. The hawkish Israeli need only point to the BDS movement
as ammunition to say: "Everyone hates us, why should we compromise?"
The more prevalent the delegitimisation of Israel
itself becomes, the harder it is to imagine activists such as Avnon putting
themselves out there publicly in support of compromising for
peace.
The Jewish nation is,
understandably, always conscious of victimisation and, whether fairly or not,
the new BDS movement appeals to a certain "us against them" in some Israelis.
Boycotting Israel, an action
that is indeed designed to portray it as an illegitimate state, rejects a two-state
solution negotiated by the Israeli
and Palestinian leadership in favour of one state.
Its premise of a one-state Palestine, open to all
religions and races, is neither just nor practical.
and Palestinian leadership in favour of one state.
Its premise of a one-state Palestine, open to all
religions and races, is neither just nor practical.
The notion that one side of
a two-side conflict should be neither able nor allowed to act positively towards
peace is ludicrous. It's telling human beings,
born by chance in Israel, that they shouldn't even
bother trying to improve their society.
born by chance in Israel, that they shouldn't even
bother trying to improve their society.
Even
more ridiculous is that this idea is being
pushed primarily by those living on the
other
side
of the world.THIS IS MORONIC
TOO!!gs Those who claim to
be
putting forward legitimate criticism of a
nation THIS IS SIMPLY EVILgs!!!
situation, MORON!!!!! should be dismissed as
extremists.
Expecting Israel to simply
fold is purely anti-Israel fantasy. And advocating for an absolutist
approach MORON!!!!!is irresponsible
when it discourages the Palestinians from dialogue, too. HEY - MORON - THE
PALESTINIANS HAVE BEEN PLAYING THIS GAME OF ''NEGOTIATING AND NOT NEGOTIATING
FOR DECADES!! ONLY A MORON WOULD USE THESE
WORDS!!!!gs
Dean Sherr
is political affairs director, Australasian Union of Jewish Students. These are
his personal views.
No comments:
Post a Comment